DALBHARAT / Q3-FY26 / claim-ledger

Audit the questions that mattered.

Dalmia Bharat · Analyst questions, management answers, and the quality of the response where the ledger is available.

Research layer active

ConCallIQ research layer

Signal, with the source still visible.

Use the controls below to narrow the view, then follow the evidence into the next layer of context.

WatchQ3-FY26 · 2026-01-20Back to quarter ↗

Questions audited

12

Answered directly

63%

Numeric claims

1

Consistency

contradicted

Question ledger

What was answered, and how?

Jashandep Singh Chhatta · Nura

direct

Clarification on incentive received this quarter and run rate.

when we said that the run rate for the next year is about 20 crores. So this new incentive is also included. So this incentive is including the retrospective side effect that is why the figures have been stated that uh 37 cr into the previous year and 9 cr in the first half but the impact will come in the coming years also that is included in the run rate of 20 crores per year.

Jashandep Singh Chhatta · Nura

partial

Demand and pricing outlook in east India given state elections.

east is uh you know one of the lowest per capita consumption regions in the country and the headroom for growth here is quite high... my belief is that e should definitely uh be slightly above than the you know national average and I think 7 to 8% growth in east should be uh quite easily possible

Jashandep Singh Chhatta · Nura

evasive

Impact of petcoke price rise on Q4 costs.

the blended cost will go up as we seen that the petrol prices have gone up but of course we'll try to mitigate this by increasing the blend of the domestic coal which is slightly cheaper

Indra Raja Garval · CLSA

direct

Progress on 150-200 rupees per ton cost savings target.

We have roughly in the ballpark of 45 to 50 rupees per ton is what we have structurally extracted... we gave a guide to the 150 to 200 we have down six quarters we are roughly 50s in the bank.

Indra Raja Garval · CLSA

evasive

Current pricing versus Q3 average and early January trends.

I think we are just 20 days into the quarter. Uh right now if you were to ask that question yes we are excited with the green shoots but too early for us to count money. Uh early signs are good.

Amit Mura · Access Capital

direct

Capex guidance for next year and FY27-28 trajectory.

So next year also we expect the capex to be around 4,000 crores and for the next two years I think the capex could be in the range of about 8 to 9,000 crores.

Amit Mura · Access Capital

direct

Realization decline and whether profitable growth strategy changed.

discounting and selling is definitely not a strategy on the table... the NSR drop is not, you know, an outlier to the industry. Uh it would be one shade better only and discounting is not uh on the table as a strategy to sell and the profitable growth remains our objective.

Navin Sardi · ICS Securities

evasive

Status of JP/Jaipur project and timeline for breaking ground.

we are now actively pursuing JP project detailing uh you know sorry JM project detailing... every single element that goes into creating the project is happening and is well on track.

Navin Sardi · ICS Securities

partial

Competitive intensity and near-term pricing caution.

the over capacity in this sector is here to stay at least for the next foreseeable future... pricing is going to move up over the medium term and I remain um you know cautious in the short term but uh you know reasonably optimistic in the medium to long term.

Panakin · HSBC

direct

Implied Q4 industry demand growth and pricing outlook.

I would this is what we expect. I think the momentum has picked up in December. We expect the same to roll on in quarter 4 might be you know a little here and there. So we high single digit is what our expectation is for the industry.

Panakin · HSBC

direct

Trade share decline and whether it is the new normal.

This is definitely not the new normal... you should look at uh mid60s to high 60s only as a future path this is what we are you know committed to deliver

Satya Jen · Ambit Capital

partial

Confidence in 75mt by FY28 and status of Jaipur and Navalgard.

on JSLM um things are going as per plan. Uh we we expect uh you know a large part of the land acquisition for grinding units etc is already done... our priority is Jesselm made right now because from a a return perspective we think that um this will offer better returns